Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

[psychostorm]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

Now there's the question that bugs me - would a sanding belt qualify as destructive grip or not?

[john]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

we was going to build one anyway so will be all fun

grant, is there prize money for the robots or just for the drags? i couldnt see on your website the break down

[RogueTwoRobots]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

Now there's the question that bugs me - would a sanding belt qualify as destructive grip or not?

I was wondering the same thing myself. Not sure if it would count as destructive or non-destructive in the 'modified' class but I was told that for the 'stock' class there is no destructive/non-destructive separation, they all run as one. So belt sanders, circular saws and grinding discs would all be fine.

[leorcc]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

Personally I feel this rule of mandatory participation in the dragraces to be able to fight in the tag team champs is ridiculous. I hardly let my own sponsors decide where I spend my time, effort, and money on, let alone a sponsor that does absolutely nothing for me. Furthermore if feel mandatory participation is the wrong way of promoting a sport.

[calumco]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

following what you've just said, i don't really agree with the powertool drag racing thing as a manditory thing that you have to do to get into the fra tag team championships, but i see the reason why, with the fact that the hall has been used mainly for the tool drag racing and the arena has be kinda put in aswell as a secondary event. but i think with this 10 pound charge of competing i don't see why you would have to then also make a tool drag racer, because if you pay the £10 pound surely that tenner gives you the right to then just enter the tag team competition if you wanted to.

[typhoon_driver]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

Grant and James have posted the details of the competition along with the requirements for entering. If you don't want to enter or can't meet the entry requirements then don't enter and wait for another suitable comp....simple.

I honestly can't see where the problem is. Reminds me of all the fuss when we had to put LEDs in our machines

[leorcc]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

Grant and James have posted the details of the competition along with the requirements for entering. If you don't want to enter or can't meet the entry requirements then don't enter and wait for another suitable comp....simple.

I honestly can't see where the problem is. Reminds me of all the fuss when we had to put LEDs in our machines

This drag racing has nothing to do with regulations or robots. This is joining two events at the whim of a sponsor where YOU have got to pay for, that is not the same.

We have roboteers here that save every penny just to get a decent transmitter or speed controller, and just to compete they now have shell out even more for a sport they are not even involved in.

[RogueTwoRobots]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

The event that the hall has been rented for is the Power Tool Drag Racing championships 2009. The cost of the hall is covered by Silverline. The Robo Challenge Tag Team championships are not a mandatory event on the FRA calendar (they don't need to be held every year in the same way that the FW and HW championships do). The tag champs are running purely for the benefit of us roboteers, due to the fact that it is both a fun competition and another opportunity during the year to run full-combat featherweight fights. Silverline have allowed Robo Challenge to erect the arena and run the event, but on the basis that every tag-team entry must submit a PTDR entry.

I thought the compulsory drag entry requirement was ludicrous at first too, but after learning and considering the above information, it seems fair for Silverline to state this requirement when you take into account that the money for the lease of the hall is coming from their pockets. Running the tag event isn't free either, regardless of the arena being set up in the hall under Silverline's lease; it'll cost the Robo Challenge crew a fair bit to run the event, transport for the arena, fuel for the transport, staff, pit tables etc. I don't know if that's what the £10 entry covers (since there are no active ticket sales for the tag champs) but if it is then I think its perfectly understandable.

I learned all of this after speaking to Grant on MSN; I'm not sure whether or not he'd have wanted me to post it all on to the forum but I think it would help provide a bit of perspective for those who are confused or annoyed by the entry rules. After all, we should be grateful that James and Grant are going to the extra effort of running the tag champs so that we are getting another opportunity this year to play full combat.

While I sympathise with those in the position of perhaps not being able to afford the extra parts for a racer, or have limited resources, its just a case of following Gary's advice and attending the next event that suits your situation.

And no, I'm not an official spokesperson for Silverline or Robo Challenge

[leorcc]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

I disagree. If the sponsor of the event (who is also the organiser I gather) wants the arena there, it is up to Robochallenge to come up with a deal that will benefit both themselves and the roboteers attending. How much money or effort a sponsor puts into the event is of no relevance to the roboteers. We had an event at Zandvoort with dragsters, dirftcars, and all kind of motorised sports. We negotiated to be a part of that, Jonno arranges to have the robots attending RIAT no strings attached for the roboteers. Whenever an EO is part of another event you make sure the roboteers that will make or break your show are not inconvenienced by that.

This sets a bad precedent, and I want to make that clear before this comes around a second time and then the argument would be well nobody spoke up about that before when we did it.

[RogueTwoRobots]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

A very valid point Leo. With exception of the information I posted above, I know nothing of the ins-and-outs of any negotiations for running the tag champs, so I can't comment or provide reasoning. The difference I see between this and the two events you mention is that RR's RIAT events and (I'm assuming) your Zandvoort event were put on with the intention of providing a show for the public, whereas the show at this event is the power tool racing, with the arena being set up entirely for the roboteers. Yes there may well be a viewing public there who will have gathered for the drag racing that will watch the tag champs but we're not putting on shows specifically for them, more a case of allowing us to fight for the sake of us fighting
This is my understanding of the situation and event at least, but if I'm mistaken on any of it I'm more than happy to be corrected.

I do agree with you Leo that perhaps some clarification or precedent setting for the future may be required to prevent statements such as well nobody spoke up about that before when we did it cropping up, especially considering that this has sat uneasily with some people and has generated a debate (at least its a healthy debate, we're not all having a go at each other's throats )

As a side note, are you hoping to attend this event at all? Would be good to see your machines up close in action again. And I really must get to a European event soon

[ady]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

i can see why people are annoyed, i do wonder why the event is being held alongside the drag racing though, i think we would be doing silverline a favour as without the robot event, they wouldnt get as many entries. im just glad their is a full combat fw arena on the scene, if i had to pay £50 a year to use this arena, i would be happy to pay it, as i imagine the costs of fabricating and maintaining a full combat arena must be higher, but also as it is the only time to get into a full combat arena. But im not really 100 % happy building something i dont wanna build or have little interest in, know nothing about, or have the time to build tbh, i would rather just pay a fee, Im doing it simply because i want to use their arena, and you never know i may enjoy the drag racing. :wink:

the same as if another eo said they would build a full combat arena providing we would pay an annual fee for the privileage of using it,I would be happy to pay it.
but i do sympathize with anyone on a tight budget/low income.
whenever i have been to a event i havent had to pay to enter,Robochallenge,RL or RR events, trophies,my wife and daughter have had free entry to walk around the space centre and so on.... free food, upclose pics of razer, terrohurtz etc... to meet the guys from the tv days, free drinks, and prize money at the end, cant be bad really.. thats why i have always gone out my way to help pack/tidy up.... usually only when i havent had to leave early!

[craig_colliass]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

I was thinking of converting my old 240v 4 grinder (I need a new one anyway) but the design I was thinking of would mean using the outside edge of one of the wooden sides of the track. so it was like a mono rail.
Is this allowed and if so can I ask how the track sides are held together? If they have plates holding them together then this may fowl the racer mechanism.

[typhoon_driver]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

Craig already asked this one. You aren't allowed walls riders.

[craig_colliass]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

Thanks that€™s my plan out of the window. :sad: :sad:

I have just tried an old 75mm (Tron type wheel) on the grinder the centrifugal force was enough to separate the tyre from the hub!!! :blush:
I think I will have to work on a gripping solid type wheel. Any ideas as I thing the winner will be the guy with the best traction.
No saw blades. :shock: :shock:

[robotwars]

Re: Robo Challenge Tag Team Champs & Power Tool Drag racing!

Quote

What happens if you dont want to build a drag tool.... ( i dont really ).. cant you attend the event?

Ok Answered ! Its a No then.

However.. I asked before....

There's a £4000 prize fund, biggest since robot wars, I thought initially I heard this was for the drag tools... is any now being put towards the robots, unless i misread, it only says trophies for robots.???


In Summary.. Am I correct.

You have to build a drag racer even if you dont want to.
You have to Pay £10 to enter.
There wont be any audience, just roboteers.
Theres no prize money for the Tag team Championships.

I think im with Leo on this one.

John