Mechanical Noise - Series 1
[[[new ruling]]]
sorry to come up with this, but I just realized I made a mistake in the ruling about Judges Decisions...
I wanted the 4 different criteria to be differently ranked in importance, damage being the most decisive factor, style the least, it doesnt work that way with the current system (with BOTH machines scores having their mark simply going up by 10) therefor, the new system will look like this:
-If the battle itself won€™t give us a winner, it goes to the judges, they will give:
A score for caused damage; (a mark out of 10)*2.0
A score for shown aggression; (a mark out of 10)*1.5
A score for control of the fight; (a mark out of 10)*1.0
A score for shown style; (a mark out of 10)*0.5
The scores will be added up and the robot with the highest score wins, a rematch will be held if a draw occurs.
Since there has already been a Judges Decision (Natural Selection vs S.D. IV), using the old system, I think it would be fair to redo this decission with the current, valid system...
Damage: S.D. IV ((7 out of 10)*2=14)
NS ((3 out of 10)*2=6)
S.D. IV did some damage to the side-skirts, but more impressive was how NS€™s crusher was nearly sawn off
NS did some very minor damage on S.D. IV€™s armour with it€™s claw
Aggression: S.D. IV ((8 out of 10)*1.5=12)
NS ((6 out of 10)*1.5=9)
S.D. IV successfully rammed NS twice, and showed much aggression with it€™s saw blade during the fight
NS rammed S.D. IV once
Control: S.D. IV ((6 out of 10)*1=6)
NS ((8 out of 10)*1=
S.D. IV was pretty much in control in the beginning, with NS against the arena wall, it didn€™t use that control for much except for some damage at the side-skirts
NS had some very solid control over S.D. IV while he was in his pincers
Style: S.D. IV ((5 out of 10)*0.5=2.5)
NS ((8 out of 10)*0.5=4)
S.D. IV€™s rams weren€™t all that stylish
NS however stylishly lifted S.D. IV off the ground, much to the pleasure of the audience
S.D. IV: 14+12+6+2.5=34.5
NS: 6+9+8+4=27
Ofcourse, this changes nothing for the course of the tournament (which would have been different when Natural Selection would have won with the new score system, which would have forced me to rewrite the second round)
sorry for the inconvenience, have a good day
[[[new ruling]]]
sorry to come up with this, but I just realized I made a mistake in the ruling about Judges Decisions...
I wanted the 4 different criteria to be differently ranked in importance, damage being the most decisive factor, style the least, it doesnt work that way with the current system (with BOTH machines scores having their mark simply going up by 10) therefor, the new system will look like this:
-If the battle itself won€™t give us a winner, it goes to the judges, they will give:
A score for caused damage; (a mark out of 10)*2.0
A score for shown aggression; (a mark out of 10)*1.5
A score for control of the fight; (a mark out of 10)*1.0
A score for shown style; (a mark out of 10)*0.5
The scores will be added up and the robot with the highest score wins, a rematch will be held if a draw occurs.
Since there has already been a Judges Decision (Natural Selection vs S.D. IV), using the old system, I think it would be fair to redo this decission with the current, valid system...
Damage: S.D. IV ((7 out of 10)*2=14)
NS ((3 out of 10)*2=6)
S.D. IV did some damage to the side-skirts, but more impressive was how NS€™s crusher was nearly sawn off
NS did some very minor damage on S.D. IV€™s armour with it€™s claw
Aggression: S.D. IV ((8 out of 10)*1.5=12)
NS ((6 out of 10)*1.5=9)
S.D. IV successfully rammed NS twice, and showed much aggression with it€™s saw blade during the fight
NS rammed S.D. IV once
Control: S.D. IV ((6 out of 10)*1=6)
NS ((8 out of 10)*1=

S.D. IV was pretty much in control in the beginning, with NS against the arena wall, it didn€™t use that control for much except for some damage at the side-skirts
NS had some very solid control over S.D. IV while he was in his pincers
Style: S.D. IV ((5 out of 10)*0.5=2.5)
NS ((8 out of 10)*0.5=4)
S.D. IV€™s rams weren€™t all that stylish
NS however stylishly lifted S.D. IV off the ground, much to the pleasure of the audience
S.D. IV: 14+12+6+2.5=34.5
NS: 6+9+8+4=27
Ofcourse, this changes nothing for the course of the tournament (which would have been different when Natural Selection would have won with the new score system, which would have forced me to rewrite the second round)
sorry for the inconvenience, have a good day

Comment