ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

[corsair_lightning]

Okay, now I have done some research, and I've discovered that ARC and the FRA fanfic community have had some collisions in the past. Though the splits are now healed, I think we should have a final epic battle for the ages.

RULES: I need 4 people(From the FRA FanFic Community) to enter 1 heavyweight apiece. Show me the stats(or where they can be located), but also show me an ARC version of your stats. This is to make it fair.

All FRA rules apply. 50% of a cluster must be dead for it to be counted out.

I don't know what I was thinking when I typed this out, but it seemed like a good idea. This will decide which FanFic community has the better robots.

[majinb]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

Mark I like a creative tournament concepts, and this is one, but as it is now there are some hits and some misses in this tournament.

first of all...

Okay, now I have done some research, and I've discovered that ARC and the FRA fanfic community have had some collisions in the past. Though the splits are now healed, I think we should have a final epic battle for the ages.

The collision between the FRA and ARC community back in the days was a very real one, a nasty conflict that got out of hand and one that luckily is a thing of the past now. Germany and France never have a brawl for old times sake either. Reading the title genuinly shocked me in a not again type of manner. Even though everybody has matured since then, I wouldnt like to touch this arguement again if it isnt nescessairy.

With that out of the way, I dont mind the idea of a tournament that involves 2 types of stats, its an original idea. I dont see how your tournament is structured though. You get 4 robots with 2 sets of stats each, how does it continue from there?

[joey_picus]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

...I'd like to say at this point I think this tournament is reopening old wounds, and it's quite possibly the most monumentally bad idea you have ever come up with...in my opinion it is very difficult to take the complexity of an FRA design and cram it all into a set of ARC stats, and while I have nothing against the ARC stat system other than that (speaking as a silver medallist in the superheavyweight once :P) I have no intention whatsoever of entering this.

[team_orr]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

i may be fairly new to fan fic, but from what iv heard the fra vs arc moment was not a perticualy good thing, and i have no interest in starting a fight (or being involved in one for that matter) and opening up old wounds is just gonna lead to trouble (in the words of malcum in the middle dynamite points at arc/fra kid with matches points at this torney)
however the idea of a torney with 2 sets of stats both confuses and interests me, its certainly a unique idea, but where does it go from here? can you please describe the format to us? tbh if you got rid of the arc vs fra thing i might beinterested in joining this torney if you can convince me
like you said, arc and the fra seem to be getting along okay, i think we should just leave it at that

[kodster]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

Mark, seriously, the feud between ARC and FRA is (largely :P) over, and it wasn't a *good* thing. Doing something like this will only cause the two communities to start fighting each other again, and not with their bots. And I don't think any of us want a relapse of that.

If you go through with this tournament, you're going to look like more of an arse than you already appear to be...

[Bblader]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

Guys grow up seriously, I expected this shit from Kody, not guys like Martijn and Joey.

It's a simple tournament. It's not about personal shit about what happened ancient times ago and it's not about creating new wounds. Nobody cares when RW Extreme did the Civil War, why are people complaining over what is basically the exact same thing? It's a simple, friendly, let's match up the two biggest Robot Fanfic communities on the net and have some fun kind of deal and Mark hasn't done absolutely anything wrong by proposing this idea.

I haven't been keeping up with the forums, and I'm sure you guys have a million reasons to hate Mark, this isn't one of them. He's doing absolutely no harm, if anything he's strengthening the bond between the communities so flamewars DON'T happen (Not like we all aren't mature enough to avoid them...well, I have my doubts about one certain user...)

Oh, FYI, nobody on ARC has any hostilities at all to this tournament, so how personal this tournament winds up being is all up to you guys. If you don't want any bloodshed, there won't be any.

[Bblader]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

I hate to double but I can't edit my post but all the same I'd like to expand on it...

Martijn. Joey. You two have been involved with ARC in the past. Your existence (and success) there proves that FRA and ARC members can communicate civilly. Why, for some reason, does that all now go to crap, right after it's just been proven that we are fully capable of doing this like gentlemen? You two of all people should especially know this. Nobody really cares about the drama that happened ages ago, Chris (Co-Admin of ARC, or is he the Head Admin? Hell not even I know how the chain of command goes down there) doesn't even remember any instance of it. And to solidify what I posted earlier, all four members representing ARC (Myself, Alex, Chris, Josh) Are nothing but enthusiastic about this tournament and not a single one of us has any intention of provoking flame wars. We don't want any drama, you don't want any drama, so there won't be any drama, bottom line.

I'm truly puzzled as to why you all are so insistent on keeping the communities separated, isolated from one another's existence, when absolutely no desire for trouble is on either end. What good does that do? Even if things truly WERE as bad as they used to be several years ago, which is truly not the case as all, seeing as how Martijn and Joey were involved in, why have this large invisible barrier of hate surrounding us? Nobody wants it there, keeping it there doesn't accomplish anything, so why the hell are we doing this to ourselves?

As said earlier, this really isn't the behavior I expected from a proposal to bring the FRA and ARC communities together, and quite frankly, I'm rather disappointed. Martijn, Joey, even if you two DIDN'T enter ARC and do very well in tournaments there [Joey, I know you clashed with the writers a few times, please don't think anything about that, it happens all the time, even between ARC staff members and/or regulars] then you two should have had the sense to realize that this is a proposal of peace, not war, now let's go smash some robots and have some fun. To react so negatively to a perfectly harmless tournament that can do nothing but benefit the two communities [especially if this is the way FRA is going to act every time ARC is bought up], well, I'm just disappointed, because it's not like you two. You guys know better, because you've seen it with your own eyes. I can't force you guys to see things a certain way, but I really wish you would see this tournament for what it is, just a bit of fun. We can help Mark make this happen and have some fun with it, possibly have some ARC guys get acquainted with the guys at FRA and vice verca, or we can just sulk away from a perfectly good opportunity and continue to act this way any time somebody mentions FRA and ARC in the same sentence, all the while recalling memories nobody cares to remember.

Now, I know I said I'm upset by this behavior, and, well, that's because I am, but it's Christmas, so I'll make you guys a deal. Either enter the tournament or agree that we really need to stop acting this way and see the ARC community as our ally rather than bitter enemy (they've shown no intentions of hostility to us, shouldn't we return the favor)? And I'll forget about the whole thing. Now who's ready to convert all this negativity into some positivity?

[majinb]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

If you look more closely to my reply Tony, and also read this one which Im gonna use to explain myself, you may find my opinion here is a bit less black and white than how you see it. I called it a creative tournament and said I have nothing against the concept of having 2 sets of stats (read: ARC stats vs FRA stats). A good idea. And Im willing to enter it in fact, but not until Mark explains how it will be set up.

If you go by the opening post here, it will be a tournament of merely 4 FRA community bots with 2 sets of stats, 1 of which is ARC style. It is not explained what this ARC style is (I know, but lots of FRA'ers dont) nor is explained that there will also be 4 ARC community bots involved, which I didnt know until 5 minutes ago when I read Tony's post. On the FRA we've been active the last 2 years or so coaching newcomers in making new tournaments, and these pointers, as well as my last paragraph in my previous post here are nothing but helpful criticism, Im sorry if I sounded otherwise.

Now for the ARC vs FRA community thing... I like both FRA and ARC, make no mistake. In my post I said nothing at all against ARC, and I dont want to bring up this conflict at all. Mark mentioned it, and I just responded that Id rather keep it out of this topic altogether. Im cool with this type of tournament, but not to settle past collisions. Thats how I interpet Mark's opening post and I would rather have a clean FRA style vs ARC style tournament with no mentions of past conflicts thrown into the mix. Thats what I wanted to advise Mark.

[andrewj]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

Tony, I understand what you're trying to say. But by doing so, I'm afraid your post has turned into an epic rant, and you're the only one causing any drama here. Martijn simply wants to understand more about how this tournament will work before committing to it. I feel the same way... in particular, if I entered this, would I be expected to RP every week? If Mark comes and sheds some light on how this tournament will work, and I'm happy with it, I'm definitely up for entering. We're only skeptical because it's a new concept that hasn't been fully explained yet.

[corsair_lightning]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

Alright, I'll clarify it a bit more:

This is a friendly tournament. While ordinarily people might think this is a bad idea, my plan is this will simply be a tournament between ARC and FRA for bragging rights. This is just for fun. That means no flaming, no ranting against the other team(you can rant for your team though).

There will be 2 teams of 4 bots apiece. One team will be Team FRA(With 4 FRA FanFic bots), and the other will be Team ARC(With 4 ARC bots).

What will happen is this:

There will be 4 2-bot matches. Each match will pit 1 FRA FanFic bot against an ARC bot. The arena will be the Robot Wars arena. There will be no house robots. Both the ARC and FRA stat sheets are used so that they can look at your bots from an ARC standpoint, and you can look at their bots from an FRA standpoint.

The ARC rules and stat-making info are here. I have given the ARCers access to my Standard Stat Sheet, and are making it to where both teams will be able to see the other team's stats in their standard format.

If you want to ask anymore questions, then please post them in this thread.

EDIT: I've thought about it. Just post that you're entering here, then send me the ARC/FRA stats of your robot to me in a PM.

[kodster]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

Well Martijn and Andy have said everything that needed to be said, so I won't go on about it. :P

Meaning that, yes, you have another potential entrant. Just heed what we've said before, Mark.

Put me down for Shadow Zone Forever (version 3) please. I'll have FRA stats up in a jiffy.

[corsair_lightning]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

And will you be representing ARC or FRA?

[majinb]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

Im cool with the tournament as it stands now Mark, PM'ed you my bot plus FRA style stats, the ARC style ones will follow shortly. Final question would be how the fights will go, ARC style or FRA style?

[kodster]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

And will you be representing ARC or FRA?

lol, where have I posted it? not ARC

[corsair_lightning]

Re: ARC vs FRA, Battle of the Ages

They'll go FRA style with a written-out fight. The judges' decision will be based on style, control, damage, and aggression, as usual. You don't have to post your tactics once each week, but I'd like it if you would.

Good point, Kody...